Is Your Business-Owned Life Insurance Compliant?

Your company owns a $2 million life insurance policy on your co-founder. That is business-owned life insurance, and the policy itself is only one part of the system your company needs. The business pays the premiums, and the company is the beneficiary. You bought the policy to provide cash if your co-founder dies, so the team keeps getting paid, clients stay, and the business has time to recover. As far as you’re concerned, the insurance is handled.

Then your CPA asks three simple questions. Where is the employee’s written consent? Who received notice before the policy was issued? And has the company been filing Form 8925 with its tax return each year? No one knows the answers.

Business-owned life insurance can be an excellent continuity tool, but it can also fail at the exact moment your company needs it if the policy, agreements, tax requirements, and intended use were never coordinated. The real issue isn’t whether you bought life insurance. It’s whether your business completed the legal and tax work around it.

What Business-Owned Life Insurance Actually Means

Business-owned life insurance isn’t simply any policy connected to a business owner. For federal tax purposes, an employer-owned life insurance contract generally involves a business owning a policy on someone who is an employee when the contract is issued, with the business or a related person benefiting from the proceeds. That can include coverage on an officer, a director, a founder who is also an employee, or another key person.

What the policy is supposed to do matters just as much as who it covers. The company might need money after losing a rainmaker who brings in $1.4 million a year, or the policy might be funding a $900,000 obligation under a buy-sell agreement. The proceeds could be meant to repay a lender, recruit a replacement, protect payroll, purchase an ownership interest, or reach the insured person’s family. You can’t assume one policy will handle every one of those jobs just because the death benefit looks large.

Picture a company with a $2 million policy where the owners expect $900,000 to fund a buyout, $600,000 to replace lost revenue, $300,000 to recruit a successor, and $400,000 to protect payroll and debt service. That’s $2.2 million of work assigned to a $2 million benefit, before timing, taxes, or expenses even enter the picture. A policy amount isn’t a continuity plan until every dollar has a clearly named job.

Notice and Consent Must Happen Before the Policy Is Issued

This is the requirement business owners are most likely to discover too late. Under Internal Revenue Code Section 101(j), written notice and consent generally need to be handled before an employer-owned policy is issued, and even then, they’re only the first step toward the intended income-tax treatment.

The notice should tell the employee that the business intends to insure their life and disclose the maximum face amount for which they could be insured when the contract is issued. The employee generally must give written consent to being insured and acknowledge that the coverage may continue after their employment ends. They must also be told that the policyholder will be a beneficiary of the proceeds after their death. Timing is everything here, and this isn’t paperwork anyone should be trying to recreate after the insured person has died.

The federal exception must also fit either the insured person or how the proceeds are used. One status-based route applies when the insured was an employee at some point during the 12 months before death. Another applies when the insured was a director, highly compensated employee, or highly compensated individual when the contract was issued. Separate rules can apply when proceeds go to certain family members, trusts, or estates, or are used to buy an ownership interest from them.

Here’s how that can go wrong. Suppose your company takes out a $3 million policy on an ordinary employee who isn’t a director or highly compensated when the contract is issued. The employee signs valid notice and consent, leaves two years later, and dies eight years after that. Because they weren’t an employee during the 12 months before death and didn’t meet the status test at issuance, valid consent alone doesn’t satisfy the status-based exception. The business and its advisors would have to determine whether another exception applies based on how the proceeds are used.

In that scenario, the business may have paid premiums for a decade assuming the death benefit would be treated the way everyone expected. Missing consent creates one problem, and failing the exception requirements creates another. Exceptions and corrective rules can apply depending on the facts, which is exactly why your legal, insurance, and tax advisors should review the process before the policy is issued, not after a claim. Timely notice and consent are essential, but they don’t replace the separate tests that govern the insured person’s status or how the money is used.

Form 8925 Is Not a One-Time Filing

Internal Revenue Code Section 6039I requires reporting for applicable policyholders that own employer-owned life insurance contracts issued after August 17, 2006, and the IRS uses Form 8925 for that reporting. The form covers the total number of employees at year end, how many are covered by employer-owned life insurance, the total amount of that coverage in force, whether valid consent was received, and how many insured employees are missing valid consent. Generally, a policyholder with one or more covered contracts attaches Form 8925 to its income-tax return every year those contracts stay in force.

That means the work doesn’t end when the policy is purchased. Someone needs to know the policy exists, where the notice and consent records are kept, who is insured, what the face amount is, and whether the annual reporting is getting done.

Now imagine your company switches accounting firms. The insurance file stays with the broker, the consent form sits in an old HR folder, and the new tax preparer receives last year’s return without the supporting policy records. Nobody on the current leadership team knows Form 8925 should be reviewed. The policy is still active, but the compliance process has quietly stopped. A policy that lasts 20 years needs a reporting system that lasts 20 years, too.

Ownership and Beneficiary Designations Decide Who Gets the Money

Business owners often say “we have life insurance” as though the policy’s existence answers the planning question. It doesn’t. You also need to know who owns the policy, who pays the premium, who is insured, who is named as beneficiary, and which agreement tells that beneficiary what the money is meant to do. Those answers determine which pocket receives the proceeds and whether the money is legally obligated to solve the problem you had in mind.

If the company owns the policy and receives the proceeds, the company controls the money, and a family expecting a direct payment may not get one. If individual owners hold policies on each other, changes in ownership, relationships, or entity structure can create a different set of issues. And if a policy is later transferred for money or other value, federal transfer-for-value rules may limit the income-tax exclusion unless an exception applies.

Add a buy-sell agreement and the picture gets even more complicated. The agreement might require a $1.5 million purchase of a deceased owner’s interest while the policy funding it pays only $1 million. Or the policy might pay the company while the agreement obligates an individual owner to make the purchase. The insurance exists and the money arrives, but the wrong pocket ends up holding the cash. Ownership, beneficiary designations, and agreements all need to direct the same money toward the same obligation.

How the Legal, Insurance, Financial & Tax Framework Applies

Business-owned life insurance sits right where all four of these systems meet, so reviewing only the policy leaves three-quarters of the plan unexamined.

The legal review identifies the policy owner, beneficiary, and insured person, along with the required notice and consent, buy-sell obligations, employment terms, and the authority someone would need to act after a death. It also checks whether your agreements still match your current entity and ownership structure.

The insurance review looks at what risk the policy is actually transferring, whether its type and amount still fit the job, whether premiums are being paid, and whether the business has changed since underwriting. A policy designed when revenue was $800,000 may not solve the same problem once revenue reaches $3.2 million.

The financial review gives every dollar a job. It measures payroll, debt service, recruiting costs, lost revenue, business value, family needs, and how long the company would need to stabilize, and it tests whether the policy overlaps with reserves, credit, or other coverage.

The tax review addresses the expected treatment of the proceeds, employer-owned policy rules, Form 8925 reporting, ownership changes, and any transfer-for-value concerns. It confirms what has to be documented before issuance and what has to continue every year. Together, these four reviews turn a single policy into a coordinated business system.

Your TEAM Is Already Invested in This Policy

You’ve spent Time, Energy, Attention, and Money building the company this policy is meant to protect, and the premiums are just the most visible cost. Your team has spent time applying for coverage, completing medical underwriting, gathering financial records, and answering questions. Leadership has spent attention deciding who should be insured. And the company has committed money to premiums that may continue for years.

Even so, your business may never have assigned anyone to manage the system around the policy. Someone needs to confirm consent before issuance, send policy information to the tax preparer, review the coverage amount when revenue or valuation changes, update buy-sell funding when ownership shifts, and make sure the family, co-owners, and leadership team understand what the proceeds are supposed to do.

Without clear ownership of those tasks, a company can spend 15 years paying for coverage and still discover the surrounding plan is incomplete. Assigning responsibility for the policy’s legal, insurance, financial, and tax life cycle is how you protect the TEAM you’ve already invested.

Holding the Business and Family Picture

This is the gap I help founders close before a death forces every question into the same week. I don’t replace your insurance professional, CPA, valuation expert, or financial advisor. Instead, I help hold the connected picture so the policy, agreements, tax reporting, company cash needs, ownership plan, and family expectations all point toward the same outcome.

That relationship matters most in the moment. When an owner or key employee dies, the family and team shouldn’t have to guess who owns the policy, where the consent is stored, which agreement controls, or why the company received the proceeds. With an ongoing advisory relationship in place, someone already knows what the policy was meant to do and can help your advisor team act from the same plan. Business continuity depends on having someone who sees the policy, the company, the owners, the family, and the advisor team as one picture.

Business Consultation: What You Can Do Right Now

Start by pulling the declaration page or current statement for every policy your business owns. For each one, identify the owner, insured person, beneficiary, face amount, issue date, premium payer, and the job it’s meant to do. Then locate the written notice and consent, and check with your tax advisor to confirm whether Form 8925 has been addressed for each applicable year.

Avoid transferring a policy, changing ownership, or updating a beneficiary based on a checklist alone, since those changes can affect your agreements, taxes, control, and who ultimately receives the money. In a business consultation, I review your policies through the Legal, Insurance, Financial & Tax framework, coordinate with your insurance and tax professionals, and help you pinpoint which pieces need attention before the coverage is ever needed.

📞 Book a free 15-minute discovery call to explore how a Legacy Planning Session  protects your whole family.